Thursday, October 04, 2007

Small World...

The Small World of Academia
'Coincidence City' . . . a bit like Jung's Synchroni-City
(Image from Fantastic Fiction)

Some readers may have noticed the blogroll links to several of my papers and may have even clicked on a few. Eventually, I'll post copies of these papers at my academic homepage, but only when I've figured out all of the quirks there.

A couple of papers that I'd really like to post there are currently online at the Catholic Resources website of Felix Just, a Jesuit and scholar of Johannine studies who was a student of beginning Greek with me at the Graduate Theological Union back during my Berkeley days.

That website is where Professor Barzilai of Hebrew University recently stumbled across a paper, "'Ethical' Dualism of Food in The Gospel of John," that I presented at the 1999 SBL Conference, back when I still had high hopes of a career in religious studies.

Anyway, I received an email from Professor Barzilai inquiring about this paper:
I have just read your interesting paper on "'Ethical' Dualism of Food in the Gospel of John" as it appears on the Internet. Your research on the uses of vinegar in early Judaic and Christian sources is highly relevant to my current work, and I would very much like to mention it. Has the paper appeared elsewhere in print form? If so, I would appreciate information about where I could locate it.
Receiving such requests is always profoundly gratifying to obscure gypsy scholars such as myself because we also receive at least fleeting confirmation that our writings are not completely in vain and that better scholars than ourselves sometimes even read the stuff.

I responded with alacrity, of course:
What a surprise that someone would be interested in that paper. And a coincidence, too, for I'm presenting an updated version this coming Saturday at a historians' seminar here in Seoul, where I live and teach. I haven't yet published that article, mainly because just as I was getting started on reworking it, I had to relocate to Korea -- where I could at least teach English -- because I couldn't get anyone interested in offering me a position in religious studies.

I've been reworking it slowly, and presenting it at conferences (e.g., St. Andrews in Scotland, the SBL international conference in Singapore, now here in Seoul). I even presented an early version of it in Jerusalem when I was a Golda Meir Fellow (1998/9).

I can send you the updated version -- and the AAR paper as well [i.e., "Gift-Giving Across the Sacred-Profane Divide: A Maussian Analysis of Heavenly Versus Earthly Food in Gnosticism and John's Gospel,"] from that same year, 1999 -- but the exotic fonts won't come through, I fear, for I've got some technical difficulties related to being here in Korea. But you'll easily overcome that limitation by checking sources that Hebrew University will have. The papers aren't much different, but I believe that I've reworked them a bit in a more theoretical direction.

I see that you are in the English Literature Department at Hebrew University. That's the sort of thing that I'm doing these days, but mostly with Medieval and Renaissance literature. I've worked on Beowulf, the Gawain Poet, and Langland, but I do a lot of my work on Milton because I can use my religious studies background to great effect on his epic poem, Paradise Lost, and actually have an advantage over many other scholars.

I happen to know Sanford Budick, by the way, but only by email. He did send me a signed copy of his book The Dividing Muse several years ago when I was at Hanshin University (outskirts of Seoul) and just getting started in Milton studies. I was trying to look into the rabbinical tradition as background to Paradise Lost and was attempting to track down the dove as Holy Spirit present at creation but found that Golda Werman had gotten there before I did.

Anyway, if my two papers are of any use, you may cite them as unpublished articles, works in progress, or as variants of my online versions at Felix Just's website.

I'd be very interested in your own work. If you'd like to have a reader of it at some point, I'd be happy to help out.

Incidentally, I see that you've done a lot of work on Lacan. One of my colleagues here is working on a book manuscript on Lacan and Taoism, Lao Tzu, and similar material. I don't know that this sort of approach would interest you, but just in case...
Professor Barzilai -- struck by some of the intriguing coincidences -- sent a friendly reply entitled "Small World!" (possibly an allusion to the David Lodge novel of the same title):
What an amazing series of coincidences you describe . . . . Of course, I stumbled on your paper quite accidently while looking for something else. If I had searched deliberately, I doubt I would have ever found it.

I'll be glad to cite your updated version if it suits my parochial interests as well as your 1999 version because -- odd as this may sound -- I was fascinated by your discussion of vinegar due to my work on the Bluebeard story and some of its ancient variants. So I truly learned a lot from your discussion.

But to imagine that you actually presented it here in Jerusalem several years ago -- to top the unlikelihood of our mutual interest in . . . vinegar, it just seems altogether too implausible. I'm still in the process of writing and so my essay is not yet presentable or digestible.

As for my interests in Lacan, although I've inevitably internalized many of his psychoanalytic theories, I'm not working in that direction any longer. My book on Lacan seems to have exhausted what I had to say. One of my colleagues at Tel Aviv University recently completed a dissertation (400 pp. or so) in Hebrew on Lacan and Christian theology. He's planning to have it translated into English with a view to publication.

And a last coincidence for the day: my daughter is currently writing her Ph.D. dissertation in Comparative Literature at Berkeley.
Fascinating stuff . . . for the likes of me, anyway. For all I know, Dear Reader, you may be bored stiff, but why -- in that case -- are you still reading? Instead, go read something more interesting, like the David Lodge novel mentioned above: Small World: An Academic Romance.

Here's a 1989 Raymond Thompson interview with Lodge about Small World and its links to Medieval romance.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Sunday, May 06, 2007

"Unpredictable Predictability"

Dany Nobus
Not Paul McCartney
(Image from School of Social Sciences, Brunel University)

Some people really know how to catch an audience's attention. At yesterday's conference, Dany Nobus, of Brunel University (in West London), gave a talk titled "Unpredictable Predictability: On the Causes and Consequences of Trauma," which began immediately with these words:
It has been a rollercoaster. I don't remember hearing any noise or blast. But I could see a strange nasty yellow light and then it all went black. I was on the floor and I felt my face was wet with blood. I did not know what had happened and I thought it was just me. I couldn't see very well without my glasses -- they had been blown off -- and I rolled over to ask someone to help me. Then I saw people lying covered in blood and I knew it was a major event that had affected the whole train.
Nobus was quoting from the words of John Tulloch, whose experience in the Islamist train blast on the subway at Edgeware Road Station in London on July 7th, 2005 was reported in The Daily Mail: "A survivor's story: 'So good to be alive'" (July 14, 2005).

Nobus was using these words for a number of reasons having to do with his talk on trauma but also because he knows Tulloch personally. Nobus and Tulloch are both professors Brunel University's School of Social Sciences and Law.

I suppose that if we believe the current cliché about there being merely 6 degrees of separation an individual and anyone else in the world, then we shouldn't be surprised to discover that we know somebody -- or somebody who knows somebody -- whose life has been personally touched or even snuffed out by a terrorist bomb. My own wife, Sun-Ae, had a close shave during a terrorist attack on a Jerusalem market in November 1998, and my brother knew Sara Low, one of the flight attendants who perished on the first plane flown into the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001.

So when Nobus observed that "As a survivor of a terrorist attack, John Tulloch is the face of our new era," I understood quite personally what he meant. And I agree with him that:

The young history of the 21st century has already taught us that violence, death and destruction can appear at any moment, in any given place, the likelihood of its occurrence no longer being a matter of "if"' but quite simply a question of "when".
Not that we can predict when, for that is simply our bad luck if we happen to set off on the next train to blow up. As Nobus points out, if we assume that "bad luck" is "pure chance," then this fact of our precarious existence calls into question a Lacanian assumption, drawn from Freud, that such a thing as "pure chance" does not exist. Nobus cites Lacan:

[W]e always point out that we must not be taken in when the subject tells us that something happened to him that day that prevented him from realizing his wish to come to the session.
As Nobus observes, this assumption made by psychoanalysis is rather controversial, for it "refuses to acknowledge that a subject to whom something happens has nothing to do with it and is therefore 'innocent'." As an example of how ridiculous the principle can become, Nobus gave the following illustration:

[L]et us imagine, for a moment, that my colleague John Tulloch was on his way to see his analyst on the morning of 7 July 2005, and let us also imagine that after having been admitted to hospital he called his analyst to explain the circumstances which had prevented him from coming to the session. If we follow the Freudian principle that nothing ever happens by chance but only ever "as if by chance", the upshot is that my poor colleague would have to start exploring the vicissitudes of his death drive, and the unconscious reasons for his symptomatic self-destructive compulsion to expose himself to dangerous, potentially lethal situations. "After all", the Freudian analyst would no doubt say, "let us not forget that for many years you have been transferring yourself to some of the most unstable regions of the planet. You better start thinking why you are so keen to seek out risk situations."
Nobus then observed that upon "hearing this type of comment, few people will disagree that it is not only ludicrous, but also cruel and inhumane."

I would agree, but surprisingly, Nobus partly disagrees:

And yet ... something about the principle, which prompts subjects not to regard themselves purely as innocent victims of circumstance but to assess and recognize their subjective implication in the circumstances, may be beneficial for overcoming the pathogenic effects of a traumatic event.
Well, Nobus is a psychoanalyst, so I suppose that he would say that -- it expresses a sort of defense mechanism whereby psychoanalysis maintains its view of the world -- but I can see his point about using the principle to help us become more active subjects.

Yet, how? What is one supposed to do? The principle might help the traumatized victim regain a sense of power, but the principle doesn't seem to do much, practically speaking, to help me avoid the "violence, death and destruction [that] can appear at any moment, in any given place."

And knowing that, I wonder how much the principle would help if I were one day to find myself the unexpected survivor of a terrorist attack.

Labels:

Saturday, May 05, 2007

Lacan, Joyce, Chuangtzu

Zhuangzi (Chuangtzu)
Contemplating a Lacanian analysis of Joyce
(Image from Wikipedia)

Today, I will be participating, as a "Discussant," in an "International Conference on Psychoanalysis and Socio-Humanities" devoted to the works of Jacques Lacan.

I must be crazy.

But my craziness should help, I suppose, in understanding Lacanian psychology. Think of my insanity as a hermeneutical key opening the way toward understanding the twists and turns that Continental Philosophy takes when it undergoes psychoanalysis.

I'll be responding to a talk by one of my colleagues, Kwon Teckyoung, who has written a paper titled "From Aesthetics to the Green Aesthetics: Lacan, Joyce, Chuangtzu." I'm not sure that I agree with everything Teckyoung has written, but more crucially, I'm not sure that I understand everything that she has written.

Partly, this stems from my own ignorance. While I do know something of James Joyce, I know only superficially of Lacan and merely one thing about Chuangtzu. I've decided to make a virtue of my ignorance and ask openly ignorant questions.

Because I have little time this morning, I'll spare you the usual boilerplate stuff and instead post my response to Teckyoung's paper, which will not only demonstrate my laudable ignorance but leave all of you pleasantly baffled since you haven't read the paper to which I'm responding. But baffled was my own experience as well, so you will understand as I have understood...
Prefatory Remarks, Questions, and a Digression for Kwon Teckyoung

Thank you for a very interesting paper. I fear that my questions will be not quite so interesting. Rather than insightful questions, I can offer only ignorant ones, for I know too little about the thought of Jacques Lacan. Of James Joyce, I am somewhat more familiar, but more as a literary artist than as a thinker. Chuangtzu, I have heard of, for his dream of the butterfly -- or the butterfly's dream of Chuangtzu -- is very famous, even in the West, but I know nothing of Chuangtzu's larger system of thought.

So, allow me to ask my three ignorant questions, then end with an equally ignorant digression.

1. Could you make more clear, perhaps by summarizing the point, how this aesthetics that you find in the thought of Joyce, Lacan, and Chuangtzu constitutes a green aesthetics, for the inner connection to ecological thinking is not entirely clear to me?

2. Could you explain more about the Median-Void and its function in Lacan’s thought? I ask partly because Guo Jian, in the article "In Search of an Unconscious: Jacques Lacan and China" (published in Ex/Change, Issue Number 6, February 2003), remarks that:
The "median-void," or the French "vide-médian," is a rather odd translation of the Chinese 沖氣 or 中氣, from section 42 of the Laozi, meaning literally "blending the breath [of yin and yang]".
[Much more can be found in Footnote 22 of Guo Jian's article, "In Search of an Unconscious: Jacques Lacan and China":
François Cheng, "Entretien avec Judith Miller," p. 54. Quoted in Roudinesco, ibid., 352. The "median-void," or the French "vide-médian," translates the Chinese 沖氣 (or 中氣, according to the 馬王堆甲本 of the Lao-zi) in the line 萬物負陰而抱陽, 沖氣以為和 from section 42 of the Laozi. The phrase means literally "neutralize (or moderate, or blend) the qi (breath or air, of yin and yang)." The line may be translated as "ten thousand things [that is, everything in the universe] carry yin on their backs and embrace yang in their arms and are harmonized by the blending of the breath (of yin and yang)."
Perhaps this is useful material to have as a reference.]

3. Could you explain something about the following passage:
Towards a mystery as well as an importance of the number three, Lacan is not exceptional at all. When he formalized the third ring as the Real in the interconnected Borromean Knot, the Real becomes the link, the Median-Void, between two opposite sides, the imaginary and the symbolic. If we examine the three rings in terms of Tao, we posit the Real in the realm of the Void, which would turn out to be the imaginary in the symbolic -- a fantasy object (a). This may be the key to solving the mystery of the number three. The three is the emblem of the ethics of Lacanian psychoanalysis as well as the emblem of Chuangtzu's wuwei because it is to follow two courses at once, to satisfy both Kant and Sade at the same time. Thus, Kant with Sade, or number three is as mysterious as the harmony of Yin and Yang.
Here is my question: How would one satisfy both Kant and Sade? Is this wei wu wei (action without action)? Is this Kant's universal moral law of categorical imperative and Sade's amorality of willfully polyvalent individual desire, the pursuit of pleasure, namely, of licentiousness?

4. Finally, my ignorant digression.

Lacan's terminology invites possible Christian connections, e.g., his expression "the name of the father" recalls Johannine expressions (John 12:28; 17:5-6, 11-12, 25-26), but the terminology recalls even more strongly the Valentinian Gnostic formulation that "the name of the Father is the Son" (Gospel of Truth 45-46; cf. John 17:12).
45. Now the Name of the Father is the Son. He first named him who came forth from himself, and who is himself. And he begot him as a Son. He bestowed his own Name upon him. It is the Father who from his heart possesses all things. He has the Name, he has the Son who can be seen. Yet his Name is transcendental -- for it alone is the mystery of the invisible, which thru him comes to ears completely filled with it. (Mt 1:21, Lk 1:31, Jn 17:6-26!, Ph 11!)

46. For indeed the Name of the Father is not spoken, yet rather it is manifested as a Son. (Jn 17:6) Accordingly, great is the Name! Who therefore could proclaim a Name for him, the supreme Name, except him alone whose Name this is, together with the Sons of the Name? -- those in whose heart the Name of the Father reposes and who themselves likewise repose in his Name. Because the Father is immutable, it is he alone who begot him as his own Name before he fashioned the eternal-ones, so that the Name of the Father would be Lord over their heads -- this-one who is truly the Name, secure in his command of perfect power. (Ex 3:14, Th 13)
Probably, there is no significant connection between Lacan's use of the expression "the name of the father" and the Valentinian formulation "the Name of the Father," but Gnostic systems generally might provide further illumination into Lacan's thinking (recall that Jung pursued an interest in Gnosis).

Anyway, these are my three questions and one digression -- which, incidentally, happen to add up to four. Perhaps I should undergo Lacanian analysis....
So . . . there it is, what I'll say today. If you see this early enough, wish me luck.

Labels: , ,