Nationalism: Ethnic and Civic
My critic mentions Foucault and Foucault's views on "privileging and legitimizing power/knowledge discourses," and accuses me of being "willing to ignore the civic community as a 'munus,'" a term he borrows from Esposito, and he says all that to say this:
The author seems unwilling to tackle these complexities, and instead simply appropriates/promulgates the ethnic/civic paradigm (gleaned from an encyclopedia) without analysis.Well, my critic seems not to realize that I didn't need that level of analysis for my paper in its original form, though I might need to do more now that my paper has grown, but what I find most disagreeable is my critic's assumption that I needed an encyclopedia to know the difference between ethnic and civic nationalism and that I simply gleaned the distinction from an encyclopedia.
I don't gotta glean nothin if I don't wanna, and I don't wanna cause I don't need to.
Labels: Civic Nationalism, Ethnic Nationalism, Michel Foucault, Science
2 Comments:
Seriously, this idiot needs to move on from Foucault. My understanding is that modern European scholarship has generally left the Frenchies behind. At least those Frenchies.
Foucault has his uses still, I suppose, but I don't need him to help me distinguish between ethnic and civic nationalism.
Jeffery Hodges
* * *
Post a Comment
<< Home